A lawyer Who Is Also a photographer Just Deleted All Her Pinterest Boards Out Of Fear

Дата канвертавання25.04.2016
Памер17.55 Kb.
A Lawyer Who Is Also A Photographer Just Deleted All Her Pinterest Boards Out Of Fear

Alyson Shontell|February 28, 2012

1A  woman named Kirsten decided to look into the legality of Pinterest.  After all, she's a lawyer with a passion for photography.

2What she found scared her so much, she shut down her Pinterest boards entirely.

3Kirsten's investigation began after she saw photographers complaining about copyright violations on Facebook.  She wondered why Facebook could get in trouble for copyright violation and Pinterest couldn't.

4She browsed Pinterest's Terms of Use section. In it she found Pinterest's members are solely responsible for what they pin and repin. They must have explicit permission from the owner to post everything.

5"I immediately thought of the ridiculously gorgeous images I had recently pinned from an outside website, and, while I gave the other photographer credit, I most certainly could not think of any way that I either owned those photos or had a license, consent or release from the photographer who owned them," Kirsten writes.

    6Pinterest encourages repinning community photos though, so Kirsten found it hard to believe the act was unlawful. She continued to dig.

7Kirsten turned to federal copyright laws and found a section on fair use. Copyrighted work can only be used without permission when someone is criticizing it, commenting on it, reporting on it, teaching about it, or conducting research.  Repinning doesn't fall under any of those categories.

8The one glimmer of hope for Pinterest, Kirsten writes, is the outcome of Kelly v. Arriba Soft Corporation.  In that case, a photographer sued a search engine.  The search engine won because it used thumbnail images in its results, not the entire work.

9Thumbnails aren't always fair use, however.  They're only fair use if the necessary portion of the work is copied and nothing more.  Pinterest, however, lifts the entire image from the original source which is not ok.

10If that didn't scare Kirsten enough, the all caps section of Pinterest's Terms of Use did.

11Pinterest writes:


12What's more, Pinterest places all blame and potential legal fees on its users. It writes:

13"You agree to defend, indemnify, and hold Cold Brew Labs, its officers, directors, employees and agents, harmless from and against any claims, liabilities, damages, losses, and expenses, including, without limitation, reasonable legal and accounting fees, arising out of or in any way connected with (i) your access to or use of the Site, Application, Services or Site Content, (ii) your Member Content, or (iii) your violation of these Terms.”

14Basically, if a photographer sues you for pinning an image illegally on Pinterest, the user must not only pay for his or her lawyer, they must also pay for Pinterest's lawyer.  In addition, the defendant must pay all charges against him or herself, along with all of Pinterest's charges.

15Kirsten likens Pinterest to Napster as an enabler of illegal activity.  It wasn't just Napster that went down -- 12 year old girls who downloaded music were sued too.

16She concludes:

17"My initial response is probably the same as most of yours:  'Why [can't I pin their work]?  I’m giving them credit and it’s only creating more exposure for them and I LOVE when people pin my stuff!'  But then I realized, I was unilaterally making the decision FOR that other photographer...Bottom line is that it is not my decision to make.  Not legally and not ethically."

Name _____________________________________ Date _____________________ Period________

Charting the Text Table

Use the table below to organize your charting statements.


What is the author saying in the text?

Here are some questions you should ask:

What is this section about?

What is the content?

What did learn from this

What is the author doing in the text?

Here are some examples of what authors do:

Giving an example

Interpreting data

Sharing an anecdote

Summarizing information

Reflecting on a process

База данных защищена авторским правом ©shkola.of.by 2016
звярнуцца да адміністрацыі

    Галоўная старонка